Select Page

Foundation for Media Professionals v. Union of India & Ors. | Writ Petition (Criminal) No. 395 of 2022

Foundation for Media Professionals v. Union of India & Ors. | Writ Petition (Criminal) No. 395 of 2022

The Supreme Court on November 7th expressed concerns over the arbitrary seizure of media professionals’ digital devices and stressed the need for better guidelines to protect their interests.

A public interest litigation (PIL) filed by the Foundation for Media Professionals through Advocate-on-Record Rahul Narayan urging the court to establish safeguards against unreasonable interference by law enforcement agencies and create comprehensive guidelines for search and seizure of digital devices.

CONTENTION OF PIL

“There are hundreds of journalists whose digital devices are taken away en masse. The issues raised in this petition are very significant because there are no guidelines with reference to when and what may be seized, what can be accessed, what kind of protection is ensured for personal data, health data, financial data…The entire digital footprint is on that one device. Once an investigating agency is involved, it’s not like the person can have a back-up…”

SUPREME COURT OBSERVED 

Justice Kaul, however, stressed the importance of guidelines to protect journalists from arbitrary seizures –

“It’s a serious matter. These are media professionals who will have their own sources and other things. There must be some guidelines. If you take everything away, there’s a problem. You must ensure that there are some guidelines.”

Justice Kaul firmly said that guidelines were required to ensure that the powers of the agency were not misused in this respect –

“I’m finding it very difficult to accept some kind of all-within power that the agencies have…This is very dangerous. You must have better guidelines. If you want us to do it, we’ll do it. But my view is that you ought to do it yourself.

Quoted Example :

The Supreme Court issued its famous Vishaka guidelines on sexual harassment, the foundation has urged the court to issue guidelines to strike a balance between the right to privacy in the digital space and the legitimate interests of law enforcement, in line with established judgments.

Judges go by Constitutional morality

Judges go by Constitutional morality

By CJI D Y Chandrachud  (4 Nov 2023)

Judges don’t go by popular morality, but by constitutional morality. Constitutional morality consists of those values of the constitution that the courts are intended to espouse such as fraternity, human dignity, personal liberty and equality.

“Judges don’t look at how society would respond when they decide cases, that’s exactly the difference between the elected arms of government & the judiciary,” he said

While the elected arm of governance is intended to be responsive to the people, judges need to follow Constitutional morality.Courts are a platform for engagement, where people feel that they will atleast have a space to exchange views and ideas to produce a new synthesis of change within society, he added.

“There is a dividing line between what the legislature can and cannot do. If a judgment points out a deficiency in the law, it is open to the legislature to enact a fresh law to cure the deficiency. What the legislature cannot do is to overrule a judgment. But this is not happening for the first time. This has been happening in the tax arena. Validating acts are perfectly permissible, but directly overruling a judgment is completely impermissible,” 

“We can’t profess to be right. We are final not because we are right, but we are right because we are final.The work we do is open to criticism and broader social dialogue,” 

Stakeholder Consultation on Priortizing heart health by eliminating risk factors

Stakeholder Consultation on Priortizing heart health by eliminating risk factors

Stakeholder Consultation on Priortizing heart health by eliminating risk factors

Raised blood pressure is among the most important risk factors for CVDs. Moreover, it remains poorly controlled due to low awareness about hypertension, lack of appropriate care through primary care and poor follow up.  Keeping this in mind, Consumer VOICE organsied a stakeholder consultation on World Heart Day on the 29th of September in New Delhi on ‘Priortizing heart health by eliminating risk factors’.

Senior doctors like, Dr U Venkatesh, Assistant Professor, Department of Community Medicine & Family Medicine, AIIMS Gorakhpur and Dr Srikanth Srinivasan Additional Professor in Community & Family Medicine, AIIMS Jodhpur and noted nutritionist and author Ms Kavita Devgan and CSO representatives emphasized on multi-stakeholder action to reduce morbidity and death from hypertension especially among the youth.

More than 50 students from reputed colleges and institutes like Lady Irwin College, Delhi, Dr B R Ambedkar and Prakash Institute, Greater Noida participated in this engaging workshop.

The session started with a brief introduction by Nilanjana Bose, Project Head, Food and Nutrition followed by a presentation on the risk factors of hypertension by Consumer VOICE CEO, Mr Ashim Sanyal. He stressed that ”As a consumer rights organization we have made it our mission to sensitize the youth and others as well and spread awareness and ensure that more and more people are screening their BP regularly and adhere to the treatment if diagnosed and avert mortality or morbidity.”

Addressing a large number of youth, comprising mainly from the public health, nutrition and nursing background present in the gathering, Dr Srinivasan said that “We have to start screening our young population early in life as stress level is the highest among todays youth. Other risk factors like smoking, alcohol consumption and obesity and those who lead unhealthy lifestyles are at a higher risk of developing hypertension. Regular monitoring of BP and maintaining a healthy lifestyle are key to keep hypertension under control.” He also used multiple images to stress on the importance of having a healthy diet among the students present in the session.

stakeholder-consultation-on-world-heart-day-img3
stakeholder-consultation-on-world-heart-day-img9
stakeholder-consultation-on-world-heart-day-img6
stakeholder-consultation-on-world-heart-day-img1
stakeholder-consultation-on-world-heart-day-img5
stakeholder-consultation-on-world-heart-day-img12
stakeholder-consultation-on-world-heart-day-img4
stakeholder-consultation-on-world-heart-day-img8
stakeholder-consultation-on-world-heart-day-img11
stakeholder-consultation-on-world-heart-day-img7
stakeholder-consultation-on-world-heart-day-img2
stakeholder-consultation-on-world-heart-day-img10

Dr U Venkatesh, Assistant Professor, Department of Community Medicine & Family Medicine, AIIMS Gorakhpur said that “If patients with hypertension can get timely interventions and have access to continuous supply of medicines, then their blood pressure is likely to be under control and adverse consequences can be averted. Regular screening and follow-up for those at risk of hypertension can help people manage hypertension better.” He also stressed that to improve India’s healthcare system primary field-level frontline workers, and community health workers and ASHAs and ANMs are crucial for delivering high quality community based services especially for hypertension and other non-communicable diseases at the grass-root level.

“India faces a rapidly escalating burden of non-communicable diseases (NCDs), particularly the rising incidence of lifestyle related diseases such as diabetes, obesity among adults as well as an alarming increase in childhood obesity,” said Kavita Devgan while interacting with the students. “The youth should be sensitized on the risk factors and the foods that they should avoid and foods that should be included in their diet to prevent hypertension, “she added.

All present at the session took a pledge to control high BP and generate awareness, and also agreed to be part of India’s effort to help the government achieve the mammoth task of 25% relative reduction in the prevalence of hypertension or raised blood pressure by 2025. IEC materials which included an informative book on hypertension, folder, book mark and calendar were also distributed among the students.

Media Coverages

Doctors, CSOs and Students express concern over the rise of Hypertension Disease Burden Rise as a Silent Killer

October 1, 2023 | News Home Live

Doctors, CSOs and Students express concern over the rise of Hypertension Disease Burden Rise as a Silent Killer

Younger generation should be health conscious: Srinivasan

October 2, 2023 | Univarta

नयी दिल्ली, 02 अक्टूबर (वार्ता) एम्स जोधपुर के कम्युनिटी एंड फैमिली मेडिसिन में प्रोफेसर डॉ. श्रीकांत श्रीनिवासन ने कहा कि युवा पीढ़ी को स्वास्थ्य के प्रति सजग रहना जरूरी है और समय-समय पर जांच कराना भी आवश्यक है, क्योंकि आज के युवाओं में तनाव का स्तर सबसे अधिक है।

Workshop on Rising Burden of NCDs & Prevention and Care of Hypertension in Lucknow

Workshop on Rising Burden of NCDs & Prevention and Care of Hypertension in Lucknow

Workshop on Rising Burden of NCDs & Prevention and Care of Hypertension in Lucknow

Consumer VOICE in collaboration with its partner, Consumer Guild organized a workshop on ‘Rising Burden of NCDs and Prevention and Care of Hypertension’ in Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh on the 23rd of September. The main objective of the workshop was creating awareness among the people on the health risks of Non-communicable diseases (NCDs), including hypertension (HTN) which is a major risk factor and also to seek opinion and participation of various stakeholders.

While inaugurating the event, Abhishek Srivastava, Chairman, Consumer Guild highlighted the importance of creating awareness among people about the NCDs and Hypertension. He informed that Consumer Guild Lucknow and Consumer VOICE are working together in the state of Uttar Pradesh to increase awareness on NCDs and Prevention and care of Hypertension. He also thanked the CMO office and NCD Cell including doctors and health workers, officials from Government Hospitals, Primary Health Centers and Community Health centers for their support and participation in the workshop. 

Hypertension in Lucknow18
Hypertension in Lucknow17
Hypertension in Lucknow6
Hypertension in Lucknow11
Hypertension in Lucknow9
Hypertension in Lucknow4
Hypertension in Lucknow16
Hypertension in Lucknow14
Hypertension in Lucknow2
Hypertension in Lucknow10
Hypertension in Lucknow19
Hypertension in Lucknow12
Hypertension in Lucknow1
Hypertension in Lucknow7
Hypertension in Lucknow5
Hypertension in Lucknow15
Hypertension in Lucknow13
Hypertension in Lucknow3

Ms Nilanjana Bose, Project Head, Food & Nutrition, Consumer VOICE made a detail presentation highlighting prevalence of NCDs and HTN in India. Talking about how timely intervention can save patients from serious hypertension problems like stroke and organ damage, she said that most Indians are not aware that they are suffering from hypertension. She raised concern about the lowest screening of hypertensive individuals and said that strengthening primary healthcare will not only reduce mortality but also significantly reduce      the need for secondary and tertiary care and its related costs. 

She informed that only 7% women, 6% men who have hypertension take medicine in India according to NFHS (5) 12% per cent of women and 9 per cent of men say that on two or more occasions they were told by a doctor or health professional that they have hypertension or high blood pressure . Technology enabled frontline health workers, like ASHAs and ANMs, can be very effective in early detection and long-term management of hypertension.

Dr. Abhinav Kedia , Cardiovascular Health officer, WHO, Uttar Pradesh shared WHO’s Global report on Hypertension 2023. He stressed that 46 Lakh deaths can be averted if hypertension can becontrolled. NCDs account for 63% of deaths of which cardiovascular diseases lead with 27% overall mortality. All people above 30 years should get their blood pressure checked at least once in year.

Dr. Rajnigandha , Balrampur Government Hospital- spoke about the behavioral changes due to hypertension which requires counselling. 

Media Coverages

                       

Empowering Women and Young Girls with Energy Efficiency: A Consumer VOICE Workshop

Empowering Women and Young Girls with Energy Efficiency: A Consumer VOICE Workshop

Empowering Women and Young Girls with Energy Efficiency: A Consumer VOICE Workshop

In a bid to empower women and young girls with the knowledge and motivation to champion energy efficiency, a workshop organized by  Consumer VOICE took place at Sanjay Enclave New Delhi on 7th October as a part of Green Action Week . The event, exclusively dedicated to women and young girls, served as a platform for raising awareness about energy conservation on the theme of sharing community and equipping participants with practical tools to make a meaningful impact.

The workshop featured a dynamic line-up of experts who shared their insights and experiences. Beena Sharma, an esteemed educator, led the discussions on various aspects of energy efficiency.

Local resource person, Lovely, shared her expertise in the context of the local community, making it relatable to the participants. Her insights highlighted the importance of region-specific approaches to energy efficiency.

Rinki Sharma, the lead projects coordinator at Consumer VOICE, brought a wealth of knowledge about sustainable energy practices. She outlined the organization’s initiatives and the critical role that women and young girls can play in conserving energy for a brighter future.

The workshop explored practical ways to save energy, such as switching to LED lights, checking for star labeling on appliances, harnessing natural resources, and adopting eco-friendly practices. Participants were encouraged to embrace these strategies in their daily lives.

Towards the end of the event, the attendees actively engaged in a symbolic act of environmental stewardship by participating in a tree plantation activity. This hands-on experience reinforced the importance of sustainability and taking collective action to combat climate change.

Enquire Now

    X
    Enquire Now